-
IntroducedJan 16, 2023
-
Passed SenateFeb 21, 2023
-
Passed House
-
Signed into Law
A BILL for an Act to provide for a legislative management study relating to adjudicative proceeding procedures.
Official Summary/Bill Text
Comments on SB 2296
Tweets
Whip Lists
Sponsors
Votes
YES: 45
- Axtman
- Barta
- Beard
- Bekkedahl
- Boehm
- Burckhard
- Cleary
- Clemens
- Conley
- Davison
- Dever
- Dwyer
- Elkin
- Erbele
- Estenson
- Hogan
- Hogue
- Kannianen
- Kessel
- Klein
- Krebsbach
- Kreun
- Larsen
- Larson
- Lee
- Lemm
- Luick
- Magrum
- Mathern
- Meyer
- Myrdal
- Patten
- Paulson
- Roers, J.
- Roers, K.
- Rummel
- Rust
- Schaible
- Sickler
- Sorvaag
- Vedaa
- Wanzek
- Weber
- Weston
- Wobbema
NO: 2
OTHER: 0
YES: 35
- Bahl
- Conmy
- Davis
- Finley-DeVille
- Fisher
- Hager
- Hatlestad
- Hauck
- Henderson
- Hoverson
- Johnson, J.
- Karls
- Kasper
- Koppelman
- Kreidt
- Louser
- Marschall
- Martinson
- Meier
- Murphy
- Novak
- Olson, S.
- Prichard
- Rohr
- Ruby, M.
- Satrom
- Schatz
- Schauer
- Schneider
- Schobinger
- Steiner
- Timmons
- Toman
- Tveit
- Vetter
NO: 52
- Anderson, D.
- Anderson, K.
- Bellew
- Beltz
- Bosch
- Boschee
- Brandenburg
- Christensen
- Christy
- Cory
- Dakane
- Dobervich
- Dockter
- Dyk
- Frelich
- Grueneich
- Hagert
- Hanson
- Heilman
- Heinert
- Holle
- Ista
- Jonas
- Kempenich
- Kiefert
- Klemin
- Lefor
- Longmuir
- McLeod
- Mitskog
- Mock
- Monson
- Nathe
- Nelson
- Olson, J.
- Porter
- Pyle
- Richter
- Rios
- Roers Jones
- Ruby, D.
- Sanford
- Schreiber-Beck
- Stemen
- Strinden
- Swiontek
- Thomas
- Vigesaa
- Wagner
- Warrey
- Weisz
- Speaker Johnson, D.
Actions
- Mar 24, 2023 | House
- Second reading, failed to pass, yeas 35 nays 52
- Mar 23, 2023 | House
- Amendment adopted, placed on calendar
- Mar 22, 2023 | House
- Laid over one legislative day
- Mar 21, 2023 | House
- Reported back amended, do pass, amendment placed on calendar 7 5 1
- Mar 17, 2023 | House
- Committee Work, House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/17 10:05 AM, Room Pioneer - Committee Work: Committee Work - SB 2296
- Committee Hearing 10:05
- Mar 16, 2023 | House
- Bill Hearing, House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 9:00 AM, Room Pioneer - Relating to limiting judicial deference to governmental entities.
- Committee Hearing 09:00
- Mar 06, 2023 | House
- Request return from committee
- Rereferred to Government and Veterans Affairs
- Feb 22, 2023 | House
- Received from Senate
- Introduced, first reading, referred to Judiciary
- Feb 21, 2023 | Senate
- Amendment adopted, placed on calendar
- Second reading, passed, yeas 45 nays 2
- Feb 20, 2023 | Senate
- Committee Work, Senate Judiciary, 02/20 10:20 AM, Room Peace Garden - Committee Work: Relating to agency adjudications and judicial deference in administrative hearings.
- Committee Hearing 10:20
- Reported back amended, do pass, amendment placed on calendar 6 1 0
- Feb 15, 2023 | Senate
- Committee Work, Senate Judiciary, 02/15 11:00 AM, Room Peace Garden - Committee Work: Relating to agency adjudications and judicial deference in administrative hearings.
- Committee Hearing 11:00
- Feb 01, 2023 | Senate
- Bill Hearing, Senate Judiciary, 02/01 3:00 PM, Room Peace Garden - Relating to agency adjudications and judicial deference in administrative hearings.
- Bill Hearing, Senate Judiciary, , Room Peace Garden - *** RESCHEDULED to 02/01 at 03:00 PM *** Relating to agency adjudications and judicial deference in administrative hearings.
- Committee Hearing 03:00
- Jan 16, 2023 | Senate
- Introduced, first reading, referred to Judiciary
Documents
- Legislative HistoryPDF
- Fiscal Note (INTRODUCED)PDF
- Marked up (Prepared by the Legislative Council staff for Representative Paulson)PDF
- Fiscal Note (FIRST ENGROSSMENT)PDF
- Marked up (Adopted by the House Government and Veterans Affairs Committee)PDF
- Fiscal Note (FIRST ENGROSSMENT with House Amendments)PDF
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/01 02:59 PM (SB 2296)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/01 03:00 PM (Senator Paulson - Bill introduction)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/01 03:01 PM (Daniel Dew - Legal Policy Director - Pacific Legal Foundation - oral testimony)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/01 03:11 PM (Jacob Schmitz - Licensed Chiropractor - Fargo)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/01 03:20 PM (Karen Tyler - State Securities Commissioner - ND Securities Department)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/01 03:31 PM (Courtney Titus - Deputy Solicitor General - Office of Attorney General)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/01 03:42 PM (David Glatt - Director - Department of Environmental Quality)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/01 03:47 PM (Johannes Palsgraaf - General Counsel - North Dakota Insurance Department [on behalf of Commissioner Godfread])
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/01 03:59 PM (Sandra DePountis - Executive Director - ND Board of Medicine)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/01 04:02 PM (Stacey Pfenning - Executive Director - ND Board of Nursing)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/01 04:05 PM (Timothy Dawson - Director - Office of Administrative Hearings - oral testimony)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/01 04:09 PM (Hearing closed)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/08 03:58 PM (SB 2296)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/15 10:59 AM (Committee Work: SB 2296)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/15 10:59 AM (Discussion of amendments [LC 23.1009.01004])
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/15 11:10 AM (Allyson Hicks - Assistant Attorney General - informational testimony)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/15 11:21 AM (Senator Paulson - motion - adoption of amendments [LC 23.1009.01004 including edits to section 6])
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/15 11:21 AM (Referenced amendment edits)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/15 11:21 AM (Seconded by Senator Myrdal)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/15 11:28 AM (Allyson Hicks - further questions from the committee)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/15 11:33 AM (Roll call vote - motion passed - 7-0-0)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/15 11:34 AM (Senator Paulson - motion - adoption of amendment [remove everything except for section 6 of the bill])
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/15 11:36 AM (Motion to amend withdrawn)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/20 10:32 AM (Committee Work - SB 2296)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/20 10:33 AM (Discussion of amendment)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/20 10:35 AM (Senator Paulson - motion - adoption of amendment [LC 23.1009.01005])
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/20 10:35 AM (Seconded by Senator Myrdal)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/20 10:37 AM (Allyson Hicks - Assistant Attorney General - Office of the Attorney General - oral informational testimony)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/20 10:47 AM (Roll call vote on Amendment - Motion Passes - 6-1-0)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/20 10:49 AM (Senator Paulson - motion - DO PASS as amended)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/20 10:49 AM (Seconded by Senator Luick)
- Video - Senate Judiciary, 02/20 10:51 AM (Roll call vote on Do Pass as Amended - Motion Passes - 6-1-0)
- Video - Senate, 02/21 09:09 AM (6th Order - Consideration Of Amendments - SB2296 - Judiciary - Do Pass)
- Video - Senate, 02/21 09:09 AM (Senator Sickler)
- Video - Senate, 02/21 09:12 AM (11th Order - Final Passage Senate Measures - SB2296 - Judiciary - Do Pass)
- Video - Senate, 02/21 09:12 AM (Senator Sickler)
- Video - Senate, 02/21 09:15 AM (Senator Braunberger)
- Video - Senate, 02/21 09:17 AM (Senator Sickler)
- Video - Senate, 02/21 09:18 AM (11th Order - Final Passage Senate Measures - SB2296 - Judiciary - Do Pass - Votes Required 24: PASSED - Yea 45 Nay 2 N/V 0 Exc 0)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 09:03 AM (Senator Paulson - Introducing SB 2296)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 09:21 AM (Senator Sickler - Testifying in support of SB 2296)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 09:27 AM (David Glatt - Director of the North Dakota Department of Environmental Quality - Testifying in opposition of SB 2296)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 09:43 AM (Lynn Helms - Director of NDIC-DMR - Testifying in opposition of SB 2296)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 09:50 AM (Art Thompson - Director of Workforce Safety and Insurance - Testifying in opposition of SB 2296)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 09:52 AM (Lise Kruse - Commissioner of the Dept. of Financial Institutions - Testifying in opposition of SB 2296)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 10:06 AM (Randy Christmann - Chairman of the North Dakota Public Service Commission - Testifying in opposition of SB 2296)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 10:18 AM (Rick Claysburg - President of the ND bankers association - Testifying in opposition of SB 2296)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 10:20 AM (Johannes Palsgraaf - General council for the ND insurance department - Testifying in opposition of SB 2296)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 10:25 AM (Brady Pelton - From the ND Petroleum council - Testifying in opposition of SB 2296)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 10:27 AM (Johnathan Fortner - From the late night energy council - Testifying in opposition of SB 2296)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 10:32 AM (Daniel J. Dew - Legal Policy Director of the Pacific Legal Foundation - Testifying in opposition of SB 2296)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 10:38 AM (Hearing closed on SB 2296)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/17 10:09 AM (Committee Work on SB 2296)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/17 10:17 AM (Representative McLeod - Moved do not pass on SB 2296)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/17 10:17 AM (Representative Satrom - Seconded)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/17 10:23 AM (Roll call vote - 3-9-1 Motion failed)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/17 10:24 AM (Representative Louser - Moved amendment #23.1009.02003 (And in addition striking the language on line 11 after the word Individual to line 13))
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/17 10:25 AM (Representative Steiner - Seconded)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/17 10:25 AM (Claire Ness - Providing neutral testimony on SB 2296)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/17 10:32 AM (Roll call vote - 9-3-1 Motion carried)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/17 10:33 AM (Representative Satrom - Moved amendment to remove section one of the bill)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/17 10:33 AM (Representative Schneider - Seconded)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/17 10:36 AM (Amendment revised (Take out section 1 And take out "Shall study"))
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/17 10:36 AM (Roll call vote - 7-5-1 - Motion carried)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/17 10:37 AM (Representative Satrom - Moved do pass as amended)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/17 10:38 AM (Representative Steiner - Seconded)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/17 10:42 AM (Roll call vote - 7-5-1 Motion carried)
- Video - House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/17 10:44 AM (Representative Karls to carry the bill)
- Video - House, 03/24 01:08 PM (14th Order - Final Passage Senate Measures - SB2296 - Government and Veterans Affairs - Do Pass)
- Video - House, 03/24 01:09 PM (Representative Karls)
- Video - House, 03/24 01:10 PM (Representative Christensen)
- Video - House, 03/24 01:11 PM (Representative Louser)
- Video - House, 03/24 01:12 PM (Representative Hoverson)
- Video - House, 03/24 01:14 PM (Representative Lefor)
- Video - House, 03/24 01:14 PM (14th Order - Final Passage Senate Measures - SB2296 - Government and Veterans Affairs - Do Pass - Votes Required 48: FAILED - Yea 35 Nay 52 N/V 7 Exc 0)
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Karen Tyler, North Dakota Securities Department (State Securities Commissioner), ND (Senate Judiciary, 02/01 03:00 PM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Bob Paulson, (Senator), ND (Senate Judiciary, 02/01 03:00 PM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Stacey Pfenning, NDBON (NDBON Executive director), Bismarck, ND (Senate Judiciary, 02/01 03:00 PM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Sandra DePountis, ND Board of Medicine (Executive Director), Bismarck, ND (Senate Judiciary, 02/01 03:00 PM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Randy Christmann, North Dakota Public Service Commission (Chairman), Bismarck, ND (Senate Judiciary, 02/01 03:00 PM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Mark J. Hardy, Board of Pharmacy (Executive Director), Bismarck, ND (Senate Judiciary, 02/01 03:00 PM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Lise Kruse, ND Dept. of Financial Institutions (Commissioner), Bismarck, ND (Senate Judiciary, 02/01 03:00 PM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- David Glatt, North Dakota Department of Environmental Quality (Director), Bismarck, ND (Senate Judiciary, 02/01 03:00 PM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Rebecca S. Pitkin, Education Standards and Practices Board (Executive Director), Bismarck, ND (Senate Judiciary, 02/01 03:00 PM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Jake Schmitz, Fargo, ND (Senate Judiciary, 02/01 03:00 PM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Art Thompson, Workforce Safety and Insurance (Executive Director), Bismarck, ND (Senate Judiciary, 02/01 03:00 PM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Jon Godfread, North Dakota Insurance Department (Commissioner), Bismarck, ND (Senate Judiciary, 02/01 03:00 PM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Jonathan Alm, Department of Health and Human Services (Chief Legal Officer), Bismarck, ND (Senate Judiciary, 02/01 03:00 PM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Courtney R. Titus, Office of Attorney General (Deputy Solicitor General), Bismarck, ND (Senate Judiciary, 02/01 03:00 PM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Lynn Helms, Department of Mineral Resources (Director), ND (Senate Judiciary, 02/15 11:00 AM)PDF
- Testimony (Neutral) -- Jonathan Sickler, (Senator), ND (Senate Judiciary, 02/15 11:00 AM)PDF
- Testimony (Neutral) -- Bob Paulson, (Senator), ND (Senate Judiciary, 02/15 11:00 AM)PDF
- Testimony (Neutral) -- Bob Paulson, (Senator), ND (Senate Judiciary, 02/15 11:00 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Bob Paulson, (Senator), ND (Senate Judiciary, 02/20 10:20 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Bob Paulson, (Senator), ND (Senate Judiciary, 02/20 10:20 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Jonathan Alm, NDDHHS (Attorney), Bismarck, ND (House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 09:00 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Jake Schmitz, Fargo, ND (House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 09:00 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Randy Christmann, North Dakota Public Service Commission (Chair), Bismarck, ND (House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 09:00 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Lynn Helms, NDIC-DMR (NDIC-DMR), Bismarck, ND (House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 09:00 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Sandra DePountis, ND Board of Medicine (Executive Director), Bismarck, ND (House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 09:00 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Claire Ness, Office of Attorney General (Chief Deputy Attorney General), Bismarck, ND (House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 09:00 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Lise Kruse, Dept. of Financial Institutions (Commissioner), Bismarck, ND (House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 09:00 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- David Glatt, North Dakota Department of Environmental Quality (Director), Bismarck, ND (House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 09:00 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Stacey R. Pfenning, NDBON (NDBON Executive Director), Bismarck, ND (House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 09:00 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Art Thompson, Workforce Safety and Insurance (Director), Bismarck, ND (House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 09:00 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Mark J. Hardy, ND Board of Pharmacy (Executive Director), Bismarck, ND (House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 09:00 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Daniel J. Dew, Pacific Legal Foundation (Legal Policy Director), Arlington, VA (House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 09:00 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- John Paczkowski, Department of Water Resources (State Engineer), Bismarck, ND (House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/16 09:00 AM)PDF
- Testimony (Neutral) -- Proposed Amendment, (House Government and Veterans Affairs, 03/17 10:05 AM)PDF