-
IntroducedJan 23, 2023
-
Passed SenateFeb 09, 2023
-
Passed House
-
Signed into Law
A BILL for an Act to provide for a legislative management study relating to vaccines for respiratory syncytial virus and vaccines developed using messenger ribonucleic acid technology.
Last Action See all actions
House • Apr 04, 2023: Second reading, failed to pass, yeas 38 nays 53
Latest Bill Text See all bill texts
Official Summary/Bill Text
Comments on SB 2384
Tweets
Whip Lists
Sponsors
- Hoversonprimary
Votes
YES: 38
- Anderson, D.
- Anderson, K.
- Bahl
- Bellew
- Christensen
- Dockter
- Dyk
- Fisher
- Frelich
- Heilman
- Henderson
- Holle
- Hoverson
- Johnson, J.
- Kasper
- Kempenich
- Koppelman
- Kreidt
- Louser
- Marschall
- Meier
- Motschenbacher
- Novak
- Olson, S.
- Prichard
- Rios
- Rohr
- Ruby, D.
- Ruby, M.
- Schatz
- Schobinger
- Steiner
- Timmons
- Toman
- Tveit
- VanWinkle
- Vetter
- Speaker Johnson, D.
NO: 53
- Anderson, B.
- Beltz
- Bosch
- Boschee
- Brandenburg
- Christy
- Conmy
- Cory
- Dakane
- Davis
- Dobervich
- Fegley
- Finley-DeVille
- Grueneich
- Hager
- Hagert
- Hanson
- Hatlestad
- Headland
- Heinert
- Ista
- Jonas
- Karls
- Kiefert
- Klemin
- Lefor
- Longmuir
- Martinson
- Mitskog
- Mock
- Monson
- Murphy
- Nathe
- Nelson
- O'Brien
- Ostlie
- Porter
- Pyle
- Richter
- Roers Jones
- Sanford
- Satrom
- Schauer
- Schneider
- Schreiber-Beck
- Stemen
- Strinden
- Swiontek
- Thomas
- Vigesaa
- Wagner
- Warrey
- Weisz
Actions
- Apr 04, 2023 | House
- Second reading, failed to pass, yeas 38 nays 53
- Apr 03, 2023 | House
- Committee Work, House Human Services, 04/03 3:30 PM, Room Pioneer - Committee Work: Relating to vaccines for respiratory syncytial virus and vaccines developed using messenger ribonucleic acid technology.
- Committee Hearing 03:30
- Reported back, do not pass, placed on calendar 7 6 1
- Mar 15, 2023 | House
- Bill Hearing, House Human Services, 03/15 2:30 PM, Room Pioneer - Relating to vaccines for respiratory syncytial virus and vaccines developed using messenger ribonucleic acid technology.
- Committee Hearing 02:30
- Feb 17, 2023 | House
- Introduced, first reading, referred to Human Services
- Feb 10, 2023 | House
- Received from Senate
- Feb 09, 2023 | Senate
- Reported back, do not pass, placed on calendar 6 0 0
- Amendment proposed on floor
- Amendment adopted
- Second reading, passed, yeas 25 nays 22
- Feb 08, 2023 | Senate
- Committee Work, Senate Human Services, 02/08 3:44 PM, Room Fort Lincoln - Committee Work: Committee Work - SB 2384
- Committee Hearing 03:44
- Feb 07, 2023 | Senate
- Bill Hearing, Senate Human Services, 02/07 9:30 AM, Room Fort Lincoln - Relating to prohibiting the use of vaccines developed using messenger ribonucleic acid technology in the state; and to provide a penalty.
- Committee Hearing 09:30
- Jan 23, 2023 | Senate
- Introduced, first reading, referred to Human Services
Documents
- Legislative HistoryPDF
- Marked up (Prepared by the Legislative Council staff for Senator Magrum)PDF
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:29 AM (SB 2384)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:29 AM (Senator Magrum introduced the bill in favor #19541)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:38 AM (Senator Magrum submitted an amendment #19542)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:39 AM (Dr. Steve Nagel - Chiropractor in favor #19519)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:49 AM (Edward Fogarty - Medical Doctor - in favor #19518)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:50 AM (Edward Fogarty additional information #19481)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:50 AM (Edward Fogarty additional information on behalf of Vera Sharav #19482)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 10:00 AM (Lindsey Jensen in favor #19463)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 10:05 AM (Carrie Roller in favor #19557)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 10:07 AM (Lisa Pulkrabek in favor #19203)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 10:07 AM (Lisa Pulkrabek also provided testimony of Alexis Wangler in favor #19491)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 10:11 AM (Tim Blasl - President of North Dakota Hospital Association introduced Chris Meeker in opposition)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 10:12 AM (Chris Meeker - Sanford Health Bismarck Chief Medical Officer in opposition #19458)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 10:12 AM (Chris Meeker additional information #19459)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 10:29 AM (Courtney Koebele - Executive Director- North Dakota Medical Association (NDMA) introduced Joan Connell in opposition)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 10:30 AM (Joan Connell - President - North Dakota MDMA 6th District Medical Society in opposition #19502)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 10:33 AM (Richard Glynn - Executive Director - Bioscience Association of North Dakota in opposition #19448)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 10:38 AM (Adam Miller in opposition #19559)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 10:41 AM (Ethan Andress - State Veterinarian in opposition #19561)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 10:42 AM (Julie Ellingson - North Dakota Stockmen's Association in opposition #)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 10:44 AM (Samatha Vangsness on behalf of Pat Anderson - North Dakota Veterinarian Association in opposition #19347)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 10:46 AM (Peter Hanebutt - North Dakota Farm Bureau in opposition verbally)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 10:47 AM (Molly Howell - Immunization Director - NDDHHS in opposition #19367)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 10:54 AM (Brenda Stallman - Executive Officer - Traill District Health Unit in opposition #19428)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 10:58 AM (Ellen Shafer - Senior Director of Communications - Aldevron in opposition #19442)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 11:02 AM (Kali Bauer - in opposition #19466)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 11:06 AM (Kylie Hall - in opposition #19496)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 11:11 AM (Hearing adjourned)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/07 11:11 AM (Recess)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/08 03:44 PM (SB 2384 Committee Work)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/08 03:46 PM (Senator Cleary moved DO NOT PASS)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/08 03:46 PM (Senator K. Roers seconded)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/08 03:52 PM (Roll Call Vote - Motion passed 6-0-0)
- Video - Senate Human Services, 02/08 03:53 PM (Meeting adjourned)
- Video - Senate, 02/09 02:38 PM (11th Order - Final Passage Senate Measures - SB2384 - Human Services - Do Not Pass)
- Video - Senate, 02/09 02:38 PM (Senator K. Roers)
- Video - Senate, 02/09 02:42 PM (6th Order - Consideration Of Amendments - SB2384 - Floor Amend.)
- Video - Senate, 02/09 02:43 PM (Senator Davison)
- Video - Senate, 02/09 02:43 PM (6th Order - Consideration Of Amendments - SB2384 - Floor Amend.)
- Video - Senate, 02/09 02:43 PM (11th Order - Final Passage Senate Measures - SB2384 - Human Services - Do Not Pass)
- Video - Senate, 02/09 02:43 PM (Senator D. Larsen)
- Video - Senate, 02/09 02:45 PM (Senator K. Roers)
- Video - Senate, 02/09 02:46 PM (Senator Myrdal)
- Video - Senate, 02/09 02:47 PM (Senator Lee)
- Video - Senate, 02/09 02:48 PM (Senator Estenson)
- Video - Senate, 02/09 02:50 PM (Senator Cleary)
- Video - Senate, 02/09 02:51 PM (11th Order - Final Passage Senate Measures - SB2384 - Human Services - Do Not Pass - Votes Required 24: PASSED - Yea 25 Nay 22 N/V 0 Exc 0)
- Video - House Human Services, 03/15 02:54 PM (SB 2384)
- Video - House Human Services, 03/15 02:54 PM (Senator Magrum - Testifying in support of SB 2384)
- Video - House Human Services, 03/15 03:13 PM (Joe Arminio - Founder of the Coalition For America's Resurgence - Testifying in support of SB 2384)
- Video - House Human Services, 03/15 03:35 PM (Molly Howl - Testifying in opposition of SB 2384)
- Video - House Human Services, 03/15 03:44 PM (Hearing closed on SB 2384)
- Video - House Human Services, 04/03 03:30 PM (Committee work on SB 2384)
- Video - House Human Services, 04/03 03:32 PM (Representative Porter - Moved do not pass SB 2384)
- Video - House Human Services, 04/03 03:32 PM (Representative Dobervich - Seconded)
- Video - House Human Services, 04/03 03:41 PM (Roll call vote - 7-6-1 Motion carried)
- Video - House Human Services, 04/03 03:42 PM (Representative Dobervich to carry the bill)
- Video - House, 04/04 12:53 PM (14th Order - Final Passage Senate Measures - SB2384 - Human Services - Do Not Pass)
- Video - House, 04/04 12:53 PM (Representative Dobervich)
- Video - House, 04/04 12:56 PM (Representative Prichard)
- Video - House, 04/04 12:57 PM (Representative Hoverson)
- Video - House, 04/04 01:00 PM (Representative Dakane)
- Video - House, 04/04 01:01 PM (Representative Tveit)
- Video - House, 04/04 01:01 PM (Representative Frelich)
- Video - House, 04/04 01:02 PM (Representative Prichard)
- Video - House, 04/04 01:03 PM (Representative Porter)
- Video - House, 04/04 01:07 PM (Representative Hoverson)
- Video - House, 04/04 01:09 PM (Representative Tveit)
- Video - House, 04/04 01:10 PM (Representative Frelich)
- Video - House, 04/04 01:10 PM (Representative Murphy)
- Video - House, 04/04 01:13 PM (Representative Rohr)
- Video - House, 04/04 01:13 PM (14th Order - Final Passage Senate Measures - SB2384 - Human Services - Do Not Pass - Votes Required 48: FAILED - Yea 38 Nay 53 N/V 3 Exc 0)
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Samantha Vagsness, Clearwater Communications on behalf of ND Veterinary Medical Association (Account Exectuve), (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Samantha Vagsness, Clearwater Communications on behalf of ND Veterinary Medical Association (Account Exectuve), (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Julie Ellingson, North Dakota Stockman's Assocation, (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Ethan Andress, North Dakota Department of Agriculture (State Veterinarian), (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Adam Miller, (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Kari Roller, (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Jeffery Magrum, (Senator), (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Jeffery Magrum, (Senator), (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Steven Nagel, Bismarck, ND (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Ted Fogarty, AHRQ (AHRQ), Ogallala, NE (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Richard W. Jensen, Bismarck, ND (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Joan Connell, BISMARCK, ND (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Mary Lizakowski, West Fargo, ND (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Kylie Hall, Fargo, ND (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Alexis wangler, Linton, ND (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Sandra Tibke, Foundation for a Healthy North Dakota (Foundation for a Healthy North Dakota), Bismarck, ND (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Edward F. Fogarty MD, MoPlatte Medical Arts AHRP.org (AHRP.ORG Physican), Spirit Lake, IA (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Edward F. Fogarty MD, MoPlatte Medical Arts AHRP.org (AHRP.ORG Physican), Spirit Lake, IA (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Robin Johnson, Hebon, ND (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- vinu arumugham, san jose, CA (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Vera Sharav, Alliance for Human Research Protection (President), New York, NY (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Kali A. Bauer, Minot, ND (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Lyndsey Jensen, Bismarck, ND (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Chris Meeker, North Dakota Hospital Association (Sanford Health Bismarck Chief Medical Officer), BISMARCK, ND (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Chris Meeker, North Dakota Hospital Association (Sanford Health Bismarck Chief Medical Officer), BISMARCK, ND (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Christine Aberle, Minot, ND (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Tara Dukart, Hazen, ND (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Richard Glynn, Bioscience Association of North Dakota (Executive Director), Grand Forks, ND (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Ellen Shafer, Aldevron (Senior Director of Communications), Fargo, ND (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Brenda Stallman, Traill District Health Unit (Executive Officer), Hillsboro, ND (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Molly Howell, ND Department of Health and Human Services (Immunization Director), Bismarck, ND (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Pat Anderson, (North Dakota Veterinary Medical Association), Bismarck, ND (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Mary Korsmo, NDSACCHO (Executive Director), Bismarck, ND (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Adam Z, Fargo, ND (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- David C. Ormonde, Mandan, ND (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Tiffany C. Ormonde, Mandan, ND (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Lisa M. Pulkrabek, Mandan, ND (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Stephen L. McDonough, Bismarck, ND (Senate Human Services, 02/07 09:30 AM)PDF
- Testimony (Neutral) -- Jeff Magrum, (House Human Services, 03/15 02:30 PM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Joe Arminio, Coalition For America's Resurgence, Wilmington, DE (House Human Services, 03/15 02:30 PM)PDF
- Testimony (Neutral) -- edward f. fogarty, MoPlatte Medical Arts (Founding Physician Researcher), Bismarck, NE (House Human Services, 03/15 02:30 PM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Allison Grabow, Bismarck, ND (House Human Services, 03/15 02:30 PM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Lyndsey A. Jensen, Bismarck, ND (House Human Services, 03/15 02:30 PM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Rocky Babel, Bismarck, ND (House Human Services, 03/15 02:30 PM)PDF
- Testimony (In Opposition) -- Mona Tedford Rindy, Portland, ND (House Human Services, 03/15 02:30 PM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- David Ormonde, Mandan, ND (House Human Services, 03/15 02:30 PM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Tiffany C. Ormonde, Mandan, ND (House Human Services, 03/15 02:30 PM)PDF
- Testimony (In Favor) -- Lisa M. Pulkrabek, Mandan, ND (House Human Services, 03/15 02:30 PM)PDF