SESSION OF 2023 SUPPLEMENTAL NOTE ON HOUSE BILL NO. 2392 As Amended by House Committee on Veterans and Military
Brief* HB 2392, as amended, would make updates to the Kansas Code of Military Justice (KCMJ). The bill would consolidate language from various provisions of Chapter 48 of the Kansas Statutes Annotated into new sections of law and repeal those sections that have been consolidated or otherwise removed. The bill would update language in the remaining sections of the KCMJ to comply with the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ) and to modernize statutory phrasing. The bill would also remove all references to, and sections concerning, trial by court-martial. [Note: Three statutes contained in the KCMJ would not be amended or repealed by the bill: KSA 48-3002, concerning who may be subject to the provisions of the KCMJ; KSA 48- 3004, concerning convictions of lesser included offenses; and KSA 48-3113, providing the citation of the act.]
Prohibition on Confinement with Enemy Prisoners (Section 1) The bill would prohibit the confinement of a member of the state military forces with foreign or domestic enemy prisoners or other foreign nationals who are not members of the Armed Forces.
____________________ *Supplemental notes are prepared by the Legislative Research Department and do not express legislative intent. The supplemental note and fiscal note for this bill may be accessed on the Internet at http://www.kslegislature.org Appeal of Nonjudicial Punishment (Section 2) The bill would outline the appeal procedure when a person punished under the KCMJ considers the findings unsupported by the evidence or the punishment unjust or disproportionate to the offense. The bill would specify if punishment relates to apprehension, a person would not be entitled to one appeal, but would not be entitled to any appeal under this section. .
Trial by Civilian Court (Section 3) The bill would state disciplinary punishment for an act or omission under the KCMJ would not bar a trial by a civilian court for a serious crime or offense related to the same act or omission. Any disciplinary punishment under the KCMJ could be considered during a civilian trial and would be required to to be considered in sentencing if the accused is found guilty.
Prohibited Sexual Activity (Section 4) The bill would outline what would constitute prohibited sexual activity under the KCMJ. “Prohibited sexual activity” would mean, as specified in military regulations, inappropriate physical intimacy under circumstances described in such regulations. Such activity would be punished if occurring between: ● An officer in a training leadership position, as defined by the bill, and a specially protected junior member of the Armed Forces, also defined by the bill; ● A military recruiter and an applicant for military service;
2- 2392 ● A military recruiter and a specially protected junior member of the Armed Forces who is enlisted under a delayed entry program; or ● A military cadre and specially protected junior member of the Armed Forces who is enlisted under a delayed entry program. The bill would specify consent would not be a defense for any conduct prohibited by the KCMJ pursuant to this section.
Sexual Harassment (Section 5) The bill would outline what would constitute sexual harassment under the KCMJ. A person subject to the KCMJ would be punished if: ● Such person made sexual advances, demands, or requests for sexual favors or knowingly engaged in other conduct of a sexual nature; ● Such conduct was unwelcome; and ● Under the circumstances, such conduct: ○ Would cause a reasonable person to believe, and such person did believe, that submission to such conduct would be made either explicitly or implicitly a term or condition of a person’s job, pay, career, or entitlements; ○ Would cause a reasonable person to believe, and such person did believe, that submission to or rejection of such conduct by a person is used as a basis for career or employment decisions affecting such person’s job, pay, career, benefits, or entitlements; or ○ Was so severe, repetitive, or pervasive that a reasonable person would perceive, and such
3- 2392 person did perceive, an intimidating, hostile, or offensive work environment. Conduct of Sentinel or Lookout (Sections 6 and 7) The bill would direct punishment against a sentinel or lookout who is drunk, sleeps, or leaves while on post before being regularly relieved. Similarly, any sentinel or lookout who loiters or wrongfully sits down while on post would be punished under the KCMJ. The bill would also provide that any person subject to the KCMJ who, knowing that another person is a sentinel or lookout, behaves in a wrongful and disrespectful manner toward a sentinel or lookout who is on duty would be punished.
Fraudulent Conduct (Sections 8-12) Adulteration of Public Records (Section 8) The bill would direct punishment against a person subject to the KCMJ if such person alters, conceals, removes, mutilates, obliterates, or destroys a public record or takes a public record with the intent to do the same. Making False Writings (Section 9) The bill would direct punishment against a person subject to the KCMJ if such person intentionally falsely makes or alters any signature or writing that would, if genuine, impose a legal liability on another or would change their legal rights or liability. The bill would also impose punishment on a person who knows a writing is false and utters, offers, issues, or transfers the writing.
4- 2392 Impersonations (Section 10) The bill would direct punishment against a person subject to the KCMJ if such person willfully, or with intent to defraud, impersonates: ● An officer, noncommissioned officer or petty officer; ● An agent of superior authority of one of the Armed Forces or state military forces; or ● A government official. The bill would state that if a person impersonates a government official by committing an act that exercises or asserts the authority of the office of the official being impersonated, such person would be punished under the KCMJ even if they did not have intent to defraud. Unauthorized Wearing of Decorations (Section 11) A person subject to the KCMJ would be punished if such person wears an insignia, decoration, badge, ribbon, device, or lapel button upon the person’s uniforms or civilian clothing when the person is not authorized to wear such decorations. Mail Tampering (Section 12) The bill would direct punishment against a person subject to the KCMJ if such person wrongfully takes any mail before such mail is delivered to or received by the addressee, with the intent to obstruct the correspondence or to pry into the business secrets of any person or organization. A person would also be punished for wrongfully opening, destroying, or stealing mail before such mail is delivered to or received by the addressee.
5- 2392 Vehicle Accidents Resulting in Personal Injury or Property Damage (Section 13) A person subject to the KCMJ who is involved in a vehicle accident causing personal injury or property damage would be punished under the KCMJ if such person: ● Is the driver of a vehicle that is involved in an accident that results in a personal injury or property damage; and ● Wrongfully leaves the scene of the accident without providing assistance to an injured person, personal identification to others involved in the accident, or personal identification to appropriate authorities. A person would also be punished under the KCMJ if such person: ● Is a passenger in a vehicle that is involved in an accident that results in personal injury or property damage; ● Is the superior commissioned or noncommissioned officer of the driver or commander of the vehicle; and ● Wrongfully and unlawfully orders, causes or permits the driver to leave the scene of the accident without providing assistance to an injured person, personal identification to others involved in the accident, or personal identification to appropriate authorities. Violent Conduct (Sections 14—17) The bill would direct punishment against a person subject to the KCMJ when such person displays any conduct involving violence toward others, as follows.
6- 2392 Discharge or Brandishment of Firearm (Section 14) The bill would direct punishment against a person subject to the KCMJ if such person willfully and wrongfully discharges or brandishes a firearm under any circumstance that endangers a human life or causes a reasonable person to be apprehensive of the potential endangerment of human life. Simple Assault (Section 15) The bill would direct punishment against a person guilty of simple assault under the KCMJ if such person, who is subject to the KCMJ: ● Attempts to do bodily harm to another person; ● Offers to do bodily harm to another person; or ● Does bodily harm to another person. For the purposes of this section, “another person” would mean a cadet, trainee, or recruit of the state military forces, the U.S. Armed Forces, or the state military forces of another state. Domestic Violence (Section 16) The bill would direct punishment against a person who: ● Commits a violent offense against a spouse, intimate partner, or immediate family member of such person; ● Commits an offense under the KCMJ against any person or any property, including animals, with the intent to threaten or intimidate a spouse, intimate partner, or immediate family member of such person;
7- 2392 ● Violates a protection order, with the intent to threaten or intimidate a spouse, intimate partner, or immediate family member of such person; or ● Violates a protection order, with the intent to commit a violent offense against a spouse, intimate partner, or immediate family member of such person. Threats of Violence (Section 17) The bill would direct punishment against a person who communicates a threat to injure the person, property or reputation of another. The bill also would specify a person would be punished if such person communicates a threat, or maliciously communicates a false threat, to injure the person, property, or reputation of another by use of: ● An explosive; ● A weapon of mass destruction; ● A biological or chemical agent, substance or weapon; or ● A hazardous material. The bill would define “false threat” to mean a threat that, at the time it is communicated, is known to be untrue by the person communicating the threat.
Distribution of Intimate Visual Images or Sexually Explicit Conduct (Section 18) The bill would outline when a person would be guilty of wrongful distribution of intimate visual images or visual images of sexually explicit conduct (images). The bill would 8- 2392 state a person subject to the KCMJ would be punished if such person: ● Knowingly and wrongfully broadcasts or distributes an image involving a person who: ○ Is at least 18 years of age at the time the image was created; ○ Is identifiable from the image or from information displayed in connection with the image; and ○ Does not explicitly consent to the broadcast or distribution of the image; ● Knows or reasonably should have known that the image was made under circumstances in which the person depicted in the image retained a reasonable expectation of privacy regarding any broadcast or distribution of the image; ● Knows or reasonably should have known that the broadcast or distribution of the image is likely to: ○ Cause harm, harassment, intimidation, emotional distress or financial loss for the person depicted in the image; or ○ Harm substantially the depicted person with respect to that person's health, safety, business, calling, career, financial condition, reputation, or personal relations; or ● Engaged in conduct that had a reasonably direct connection to a military mission or military environment. The bill would also define certain terms for purposes of the section.
9- 2392 Perjury and Obstruction of Justice (Sections 19—24) Inducing False Testimony Under Oath (Section 19) The bill would direct punishment against a person subject to the KCMJ if such person induces another person to take an oath and falsely testify, depose, or make a statement upon such oath. In order for a person to be punished for this conduct: ● The oath would have to be administered as required by law, and by a person that has the authority to do so; ● Upon taking such oath, the other person willfully makes or attests to a false statement that is material to the proceedings; and ● When the statement is made or attested to, the person subject to the KCMJ and the person induced into such conduct do not believe such statement is true. Obstruction of Justice (Section 20) The bill would direct punishment against a person subject to the KCMJ if such person engages in conduct intending to influence, impede, or otherwise obstruct the due administration of justice. Duty to Report Offense (Section 21) The bill would direct punishment against a person subject to the KCMJ if such person: ● Knows another person has committed a serious offense; and
10- 2392 ● Wrongfully conceals the commission of the offense and fails to make the commission of the offense known to civilian or military authorities as soon as possible. Duty to Cooperate With Judicial Proceedings (Section 22) The bill would direct punishment against a person subject to the KCMJ if such person wrongfully refuses to qualify as a witness or wrongfully refuses to answer a question after having been directed to do so by a presiding authority in certain judicial proceedings, as specified by the bill. Search and Seizure (Section 23) The bill would direct punishment against a person subject to the KCMJ if such person knows that one or more persons authorized to make searches and seizures are seizing, about to seize, or are endeavoring to seize property and then destroy, remove, or otherwise dispose of the property with the intent to prevent the seizure of such property. Obstruction of Pending Administrative Action (Section 24) The bill would direct punishment against a person subject to the KCMJ if such person has reason to believe that an adverse administrative action is pending against any person subject to the KCMJ and either: ● Intentionally acts to influence, impede, or obstruct the conduct of the proceeding; or ● Acts to obstruct the due administration of justice.
11- 2392 Bribery (Sections 25 and 26) The bill would direct punishment against a person subject to the KCMJ if such person occupies an official position or has official duties and wrongfully asks for, accepts, or receives something of value with the intent to have the person's decision or action influenced regarding an official matter in which the state of Kansas or the United States is interested. The bill would direct punishment against a person subject to the KCMJ if such person wrongfully promises, offers, or gives something of value to a person who occupies an official position or has official duties and intends to influence the decisions or actions of the person regarding an official manner in which the state of Kansas or the Unites States is interested. The bill would direct punishment against a person subject to the KCMJ if such person occupies an official position or has official duties and wrongfully asks for, accepts, or receives something of value as compensation for or in recognition of services rendered or to be rendered by the person regarding an official matter in which the state of Kansas or the United States is interested. The bill would direct punishment against a person subject to the KCMJ if such person promises, offers, or gives something of value to a person who occupies an official position or who has official duties as compensation for or in recognition of services rendered by such person regarding an official matter in which the state of Kansas or the United