Existing law sets forth the Nevada Ethics in Government Law (Ethics Law) which establishes statutory ethical standards to govern the conduct of public officers and employees. (Chapter 281A of NRS)
Under existing law, the code of ethical standards, with certain exceptions, prohibits a public officer or employee other than a State Legislator from using governmental time, property, equipment or other facilities to benefit a significant or pecuniary interest of the public officer or employee or any person to whom the public officer or employee has a commitment in a private capacity. (NRS 281A.400) Section 14 of this bill instead prohibits, with certain exceptions, a public officer or employee from knowingly using public resources for the primary purpose of benefitting such interests. Existing law additionally prohibits a State Legislator from using governmental time, property, equipment or other facilities for a nongovernmental purpose or for the private benefit of the State Legislator or any other person. (NRS 281A.400) Section 14 instead prohibits a State Legislator from knowingly using public resources for such purposes.
Existing law creates the Commission on Ethics and sets forth the membership of the Commission, providing that the terms of members are 4 years and prohibiting a member from serving more than two consecutive terms. (NRS 281A.200) Section 10 of this bill prohibits a member of the Commission from serving for more than 12 years and requires, if the service of the member meets this 12-year limit during his or her term, his or her seat to be declared vacant and filled by the appropriate appointing authority for the unexpired term. Section 26 of this bill prohibits any time served as a member of the Commission before July 1, 2027, from being counted toward the 12-year limit imposed by section 10.
Section 11 of this bill provides that the Executive Director appointed by the Commission serves at the pleasure of the Commission and authorizes the Commission to remove the Executive Director, with or without cause, by a majority vote. (NRS 281A.230)
Existing law establishes procedures governing the filing, consideration and disposition of ethics complaints which may be filed with the Commission by certain persons and entities or initiated by the Commission on its own motion. (NRS 281A.710-281A.790) Sections 4, 5, 9, 12, 16-18 and 20-22 of this bill revise these procedures to: (1) reflect revisions made to the jurisdiction of the Commission relating to certain financial disclosure statements; (2) remove from the Commission the authority to file an ethics complaint on its own motion and render an opinion on ethics complaints filed by certain persons; (3) authorize a public officer or employee who is the subject of an ethics complaint to request the informal disposition of an ethics complaint by certain stipulated agreements; and (4) establish procedures for holding an adjudicatory hearing when the Commission or a review panel of the Commission rejects certain agreements proposed by a person who is the subject of an ethics complaint.
Existing law requires the Commission to determine whether it has jurisdiction and whether an investigation into an ethics complaint is warranted within 45 days after receiving the complaint. (NRS 281A.715) Section 19 of this bill instead requires the Commission to make such determinations within 30 business days.
Existing law authorizes the Executive Director and a public officer or employee who is the subject of an ethics complaint to develop a deferral agreement to defer further proceedings in the matter and requires such an agreement to be approved by a review panel. (NRS 281A.730, 281A.740) Section 23 of this bill also authorizes a public officer or employee to propose such a deferral agreement on his or her own behalf. If a review panel does not approve such a deferral agreement, sections 5 and 22 require an adjudicatory hearing to be held.
Section 13 of this bill requires the Commission to submit to the Governor and the Director of the Legislative Counsel Bureau for transmittal to the Legislature an annual report concerning the filing, consideration and disposition of ethics complaints in the immediately preceding calendar year.
Section 6 of Article 4 of the Nevada Constitution invests each House of the Legislature with plenary and exclusive constitutional powers to govern, control and regulate its membership and its internal organization, affairs and management. In 2009, the Nevada Supreme Court held that disciplinary power over State Legislators for conduct that is a core legislative function, such as voting, is a function that is constitutionally committed to each House and cannot be delegated to another branch of Government, including the Commission on Ethics as part of the Executive Branch. (Commission on Ethics v. Hardy, 125 Nev. 285, 296 (2009)) The Court also, however, provided that this prohibition only extended to core legislative functions and that the Legislature may delegate disciplinary powers with respect to noncore legislative functions. (Commission on Ethics v. Hardy, 125 Nev. 285, 296 n.9 (2009)) In 2009, the Legislature enacted Senate Bill No. 160 which included amendments to the Ethics Law to reflect these constitutional principles by prohibiting the Commission from exercising jurisdiction or authority over or inquiring into, intruding upon or interfering with the functions of a State Legislator that are protected by legislative privilege and immunity pursuant to the Nevada Constitution or certain provisions of Nevada law which codify long-standing constitutional doctrines, including separation of powers and legislative privilege or immunity. (NRS 281A.020, 281A.420) Under existing law, therefore, the Commission maintains concurrent jurisdiction with each House to regulate, discipline and punish members for actions that fall outside the sphere of legitimate legislative activity and violate the Ethics Law. Under such circumstances, a member may be disciplined or punished by the member's own House or the Commission on Ethics, or by both. (NRS 281A.020, 281A.280, 281A.785, 281A.790)
Sections 3, 6, 8, 12, 15 and 24 of this bill remove from the Commission such jurisdiction, delegating to each House the exclusive jurisdiction to regulate, discipline and punish members for all actions of State Legislators that fall outside the sphere of legitimate legislative activity and violate the Ethics Law. Section 3 provides that the conduct of a former State Legislator who holds a new position, other than State Legislator, as a public officer or employee is subject to the jurisdiction of the Commission unless otherwise provided by law.
Section 2 of this bill defines the term “business day” for purposes of the Ethics Law.
Section 27 of this bill provides that: (1) the amendatory provisions of this bill limiting the jurisdiction of the Commission on Ethics apply to an ethics complaint or proceeding that is pending before the Commission on July 1, 2027; and (2) the amendatory provisions of this bill do not apply to any conduct occurring before July 1, 2027.