The Florida Senate
BILL ANALYSIS AND FISCAL IMPACT STATEMENT
(This document is based on the provisions contained in the legislation as of the latest date listed below.)
Prepared By: The Professional Staff of the Committee on Fiscal Policy
BILL: CS/SB 1222
INTRODUCER: Criminal Justice Committee; Senator Trumbull and others
SUBJECT: Theft
DATE: February 20, 2024 REVISED:
ANALYST STAFF DIRECTOR REFERENCE ACTION
1. Vaughan Stokes CJ Fav/CS
2. Atchley Harkness ACJ Favorable
3. Vaughan Yeatman FP Favorable
Please see Section IX. for Additional Information:
PLEASE MAKE SELECTION
I. Summary:
CS/SB 1222 amends s. 812.04, F.S., to specify the threshold value for third degree felony theft
from a dwelling or unenclosed curtilage of a dwelling from $100 or more, but less than $750, to
$40 or more, but less than $750. This crime retains a level 2 in the offense severity ranking chart.
The bill creates new crimes relating to taking property from a person’s home or porch.
Specifically, if the property is taken from a dwelling or from the unenclosed curtilage of a
dwelling, it is a:
Third degree felony, if the property stolen is valued at $750 or more. This crime is ranked as
a level 4 in the offense severity ranking chart.
Second degree felony, if the property stolen is taken from more than 20 dwellings or from the
unenclosed curtilage of more than 20 dwellings, or any combination thereof. This crime is
ranked as a level 5 in the offense severity ranking chart.
First degree misdemeanor, if the property stolen is valued at less than $40.
o A person who commits the above misdemeanor offense and who has previously been
convicted of any theft commits a third degree felony. This crime is ranked as a level 2 in
the offense severity ranking chart.
o A person who commits the above misdemeanor offense and has previously been
convicted two or more times of any theft commits a third degree felony. This crime is
ranked as a level 4 in the offense severity ranking chart.
BILL: CS/SB 1222 Page 2
The bill amends s. 812.015, F.S., to provide that it is a third degree felony for a person to commit
retail theft if the person acts in concert with five or more other persons within one or more
establishments for the purpose of overwhelming the response of a merchant, merchant’s
employee, or law enforcement officer in order to carry out the offense or avoid detection or
apprehension for the offense. This crime is listed as a level 5 in the offense severity ranking
chart.
Commission of the offense described above is a second degree felony if the person solicits the
participation of another person in the offense through the use of a social media platform. This
crime is listed as a level 6 in the offense severity ranking chart.
The bill provides it is a first degree felony, if a person commits retail theft under s. 812.015(8) or
(9), F.S., and:
Has two or more previous convictions of violations of either or both of those subsections; or
Possesses a firearm during the commission of such offense. This crime is listed as a level 8 in
the offense severity ranking chart.
Additionally, the bill amends the aggregation criteria for specified retail theft offenses. For retail
theft offenses under ss. 812.015(8), 812.015(9), and 812.015(10), F.S., where a specified number
of retail thefts, specified value of property stolen, or specified number of items stolen, is
aggregated to determine the total number of retail thefts or value of property stolen, the bill
increases the aggregation period from 30 days to 45 days.
The bill has a positive significant prison bed impact. See Section V., Fiscal Impact Statement.
The bill provides an effective date of October 1, 2024.
II. Present Situation:
Retail merchants have experienced an increase in property theft referred to as “smash-and grab”
theft. In this form of organized retail crime, a large group of offenders enter a retail store and
steal thousands of dollars of products in minutes, typically overpowering the merchant’s
employees and preventing the merchant from stopping the theft. Law enforcement has reported
such offenders utilizing social media to coordinate illegal group activity.
At the Nordstrom store in California, for example, thieves raided the store of over $100,000 of
merchandise in one minute and left the scene in 25 separate cars.1 In December 2023, a smash
and grab burglary at the Sawgrass Mills Mall in Sunrise, led to panic when suspects used an
unknown device to break display glass generating a loud noise.2
1
The San Francisco Chronical Business Insider, Jessica Chastain, Smash-and-Grab Robberies Organized on Social Media,
Police Say, available at, https://www.businessinsider.com/smash-and-grab-robberies-organized-on-social-media-police-2021-
12 (last visited on January 20, 2024).
2
7 News, Miami, Brandon Beyer, Ruben Rosario and Robbin Simmons, Police: Shattered glass during “smash and grab” at
Sawgrass Mills Mall leads to panic, available at, https://wsvn.com/news/local/broward/police-shattered-glass-during-smash-
and-grab-at-sawgrass-mills-mall-leads-to-panic/ (Last visited January 20, 2024).
BILL: CS/SB 1222 Page 3
Porch Pirating is a theft crime that has also increased in recent years. “Porch pirate”3 is a term
that refers to a thief who takes packages left outside doors by couriers. As online shopping
continues to be on the rise, so do incidences of porch piracy. Nearly eight in ten Americans have
reported falling victim to such package theft in 2022, totaling an estimated 260 million packages
worth $19.5 billion.4
Theft
Section 812.014, F.S., provides that a person commits a theft if he or she knowingly obtains or
uses, or endeavors to obtain or to use, the property of another with intent to either temporarily or
permanently:
Deprive the other person of a right to the property or a benefit from the property; or
Appropriate the property to his or her own use or to the use of any person not entitled to use
the property.5
Generally, a person commits a third degree felony6 crime of grand theft if the property stolen is
valued at $750 or more, but less than $20,000.7 If the property stolen is $20,000 or more, but less
than $100,000, the offender commits a second degree felony,8 and if the property stolen is
$100,000 or more, the offender commits a first degree felony.9 Other items listed under this
section such as the theft of a firearm, a motor vehicle, or a stop sign, may also constitute grand
theft.10
Taking Property from a Dwelling or the Unenclosed Curtilage of a Dwelling
Section 812.014, F.S., defines theft offenses and categorizes the offense level based on the value
of the property stolen and the offender’s prior history of theft convictions, the circumstances
under which the theft occurs, or the type of property stolen to determine the level of offense.
Specifically, s. 812.014(2)(d), F.S., prohibits a person from stealing property valued at $100 or
more, but less than $750, when property is taken from a dwelling or the unenclosed curtilage of a
dwelling. A violation of the prohibition is a third degree felony and ranked as a Level 2 offense
on the offense severity ranking chart of the Criminal Punishment Code.
A dwelling is defined as a building or conveyance of any kind, including any attached porch,
whether such building or conveyance is temporary or permanent, mobile or immobile, which has
3
Dictionary.com definition of porch pirate.
4
Forbes, Ana Durrani, The Worst states for Porch Pirates 2024, https://www.forbes.com/home-improvement/home-
security/worst-states-for-porch-
pirates/#:~:text=Nearly%20eight%20in%2010%20Americans%20have%20had%20packages,million%20packages%20estima
ted%20at%20%2419.5%20billion%20in%202022 (last visited January 20, 2024).
5
Section 812.014(1), F.S.
6
A third degree felony is generally punishable by not more than 5 years in state prison and a fine not exceeding $5,000.
Sections 775.082 and 775.083, F.S.
7
Section 812.014(2)(c)1.-3., F.S.
8
Section 812.014(2)(b), F.S.
9
Section 812.014(2)(a)1., F.S.
10
Section 812.014(2)(c), F.S.
BILL: CS/SB 1222 Page 4
a roof over it and is designed to be occupied by people lodging therein at night, together with the
curtilage thereof.11
Unenclosed curtilage of a dwelling is defined as the unenclosed land or grounds, and any
outbuildings that are directly and intimately adjacent to and connected with the dwelling and
necessary, convenient, and habitually used in connection with that dwelling.12
Retail Theft
Retail theft is the taking possession of or carrying away of merchandise, property, money, or
negotiable documents; altering or removing a label, universal product code, or price tag;
transferring merchandise from one container to another; or removing a shopping cart, with intent
to deprive the merchant of possession, use, benefit, or full retail value.13
Under s. 812.015(8)(a)-(f), F.S., retail theft is a third degree felony, if a person:
Individually, or in concert with one or more other persons, coordinates the activities of one or
more individuals in committing the offense, which may occur through multiple acts of retail
theft, in which the amount of each individual theft is aggregated within a 30-day period to
determine the value of the property stolen and such value is $750 or more.
Conspires with another person to commit retail theft with the intent to sell the stolen property
for monetary or other gain, and subsequently takes or causes such property to be placed in
the control of another person in exchange for consideration, in which the stolen property
taken or placed within a 30-day period is aggregated to determine the value of the stolen
property and such value is $750 or more.
Acts in concert with one or more other individuals within one or more establishments to
distract the merchant, merchant’s employee, or law enforcement officer in order to carry out
the offense, or acts in other ways to coordinate efforts to carry out the offense and such value
is $750 or more.
Commits the offense through the purchase of merchandise in a package or box that contains
merchandise other than, or in addition to, the merchandise purposed to be contained in the
package or box and such value is $750 or more.
Individually, or in concert with 1 or more other persons, commits 5 or more retail thefts
within a 30-day period and in committing such thefts obtains or uses 10 or more items of
merchandise, and the number of items stolen during each theft is aggregated within the 30-
day period to determine the total number of items stolen, regardless of the value of the
merchandise, and two or more of the thefts occur at different physical locations.
Under s. 812.015(9)(a)-(c), F.S., retail theft is a second degree felony if a person:
Commits a second or subsequent felony retail theft offense.
Individually, or in concert with one or more other persons, coordinates the activities of one or
more persons in committing the offense of retail theft, in which the amount of each
individual theft within a 30-day period is aggregated to determine the value of the stolen
property and such value is in excess of $3,000.
11
Section s. 810.011(2), F.S.
12
Section 810.09, F.S.
13
Section 812.015(1)(d), F.S.
BILL: CS/SB 1222 Page 5
Conspires with another person to commit retail theft with the intent to sell the stolen property
for monetary or other gain, and subsequently takes or causes such property to be placed in
control of another person in exchange for consideration, in which the stolen property taken or
placed within a 30-day period is aggregated to have a value in excess of $3,000.
Under s. 812.015(9)(d), F.S., retail theft is a second degree felony, regardless of the value of
property stolen, if a person individually, or in concert with one or more other persons, commits
five or more retail thefts within a 30-day period and in committing such thefts obtains or uses 20
or more items of merchandise, and the number of items stolen during each theft is aggregated
within the 30-day period to determine the total number of items stolen, regardless of the value of
such merchandise, and two or more of the thefts occur at a different physical retail merchant
location.
Criminal Punishment Code
The maximum sentence that can be imposed for a criminal offense is generally based on the
degree of the misdemeanor or felony:
Sixty days in a county jail for a second degree misdemeanor;
One year in a county jail for a first degree misdemeanor;
Five years in state prison for a third degree felony;
Fifteen years in state prison for a second degree felony; and
Generally, 30 years in state prison for a first degree felony.14
The Criminal Punishment Code15 (Code) is Florida’s primary sentencing policy. Noncapital
felonies sentenced under the Code receive an offense severity level ranking (Levels 1-10).16
Points are assigned and accrue based upon the offense severity level ranking assigned to the
primary offense, additional offenses, and prior offenses. Sentence points escalate as the severity
level escalates. Points may also be added or multiplied for other factors such as victim injury or
the commission of certain offenses. The lowest permissible sentence is any non-state prison
sanction in which total sentence points equal or are less than 44 points, unless the court
determines that a prison sentence is appropriate. If total sentence points exceed 44 points, the
lowest permissible sentence in prison months is calculated by subtracting 28 points from the total
sentence points and decreasing the remaining total by 25 percent.17 Absent mitigation,18 the
permissible sentencing range under the Code is generally the lowest permissible sentence scored
up to and including the maximum penalty provided under s. 775.082, F.S.19
14
Section 775.082, F.S. Fines may also be imposed, and those fines escalate based on the degree of the offense.
Section 775.083, F.S., provides the following maximum fines; $500 for a second degree misdemeanor; $1,000 for a first
degree misdemeanor; $5,000 for a third degree felony; and $10,000 for a second degree felony and a first degree felony.
15
Sections 921.002-921.0027, F.S. See chs. 97-194 and 98-204, L.O.F. The Code is effective for offenses committed on or
after October 1, 1998.
16
Offenses are either ranked in the offense severity level ranking chart in s. 921.0022, F.S., or are ranked by default based on
a ranking assigned to the felony degree of the offense as provided in s. 921.0023, F.S.
17
Section 921.0024, F.S. Unless otherwise noted, information on the Code is from this source.
18
The court may “mitigate” or “depart downward” from the scored lowest permissible sentence, if the court finds a
mitigating circumstance. Section 921.0026, F.S., provides a list of mitigating circumstances.
19
If the scored lowest permissible sentence exceeds the maximum penalty in s. 775.082, F.S., the sentence required by the
Code must be imposed. If total sentence points are greater than or equal to 363 points, the court may sentence the offender to
life imprisonment. Section 921.0024(2), F.S.
BILL: CS/SB 1222 Page 6
Offense Severity Ranking Chart
Section 921.0022(1) and (2), F.S., provides the offense severity ranking chart that must be used
with the Criminal Punishment Code worksheet to compute a sentence score for each felony
offender whose offense was committed on or after October 1, 1998. The chart has 10 offense
levels, ranked from least severe to most severe.
Section 921.0023, F.S., provides that until the Legislature specifically assigns an offense to a
severity level in the offense severity ranking chart, the severity level is within the following
parameters:
A third degree felony is within offense level 1;
A second degree felony is within offense level 4;
A first degree felony is within offense level 7;
A first degree punishable by life felony is within offense level 9; and
A life felony is within offense level 10.
III. Effect of Proposed Change